Days of our lives spoilers: BIG RUMOR! Andrea Hall Returns to DOOL to Replace Deidre Hall

Could Andrea Hall Return to Days of Our Lives? A Twin Twist That Could Rock Salem

Welcome, loyal Days of Our Lives fans, to another edition of TV Days Drama Digest, your home for deep dives into the wildest, most nostalgic, and juiciest rumors from Salem. Today’s speculation hits straight at the heart of legacy, drama, and real-life family magic.

Could Andrea Hall, the real-life twin sister of longtime fan-favorite Deidre Hall (Dr. Marlena Evans), return to Days of Our Lives? With the soap gearing up for its monumental 60th anniversary in November 2025, the timing could be perfect for a bold comeback that blends past and present in spectacular fashion.

Let’s explore the history, current show dynamics, and future possibilities that make Andrea Hall’s return not only plausible—but potentially explosive.

A Legacy Written in Twin Ink: Andrea and Deidre Hall’s Shared History

For diehard DOOL fans, the Hall twins’ legacy is unforgettable. Andrea Hall carved her name into Salem lore during two unforgettable stints, first in the late 1970s and again in the early 2000s. Using the sisters’ uncanny resemblance, the show crafted some of its most legendary twin-centric storylines.

Andrea first portrayed Samantha Evans, Marlena’s troubled and envious identical twin, in 1977. A struggling actress battling addiction, Samantha’s deep-seated jealousy led her down a path of impersonation, deception, and ultimately tragedy. Her chilling scheme to institutionalize Marlena left fans riveted, but Samantha’s time ended in heartbreak when she was mistakenly murdered by the Salem Strangler—a twist that shook fans to their core.

Fast forward to 2000, Andrea returned as Hattie Adams, a lookalike not related to Marlena, who was manipulated by Stefano DiMera in one of his classic villainous ploys. Hattie started as a pawn but gradually won over fans with her rough-edged humor and underdog vulnerability. Andrea’s Hattie was memorable and layered, appearing until 2001. Deidre later assumed the role in 2004 and revisited it periodically between 2016 and 2020—including a brief stint in September 2024.

The real-life twin dynamic lent a tangible spark to both portrayals. Deidre has frequently spoken about how working with Andrea was one of her career’s highlights.

Why Now? The Perfect Storm for a Comeback

With Days of Our Lives building toward its 60th anniversary and embracing bold, legacy-rich storytelling, the return of Andrea Hall could be the perfect nostalgic jolt.

Executive producer Ken Corday has teased that the show is preparing “game-changing developments” as part of this historic season. One of the biggest? The resurrection of Stefano DiMera, Salem’s eternal puppet master. Rumors point to his return involving high-tech deception, which means lookalikes, clones, and doppelgängers are all on the table.

And no character is more tied to Stefano’s manipulations than Hattie Adams. This opens the door for Andrea’s return in several ways—some familiar, some brand new.

Three Explosive Possibilities for Andrea Hall’s Return

1. Hattie Adams: The Redemption Arc

After years of being used and cast aside, what if Hattie returns to Salem with a mission? Perhaps she’s seeking closure—or revenge. Imagine Hattie discovering that Stefano is back and more dangerous than ever. Could she join forces with Marlena to take him down?

The arc would offer high-stakes emotional depth, humor, and redemption—along with the rare chance to watch Andrea and Deidre share scenes as allies instead of rivals.

2. A New Long-Lost Twin or Lookalike

Soap operas love lost twins and family secrets. Could Andrea portray a third doppelgänger? Perhaps a previously unknown sibling—maybe a result of Stefano’s cloning experiments or a secret child of one of the Hortons or Bradys?

With Peacock now backing DOOL, there’s room for serialized arcs that take creative risks. Imagine a shocking reveal that redefines Marlena’s family tree just as the town braces for Stefano’s latest mind game.

3. Temporary Replacement for Marlena

At 77 years old, Deidre Hall may soon take a brief break from the show. If that happens, Andrea could temporarily step into Marlena’s shoes—a classic soap trope with endless story potential.

Whether it’s Hattie impersonating Marlena for strategic reasons or Andrea simply standing in while Deidre takes a breather, the real-life twin switch could inject chaos, confusion, and drama into existing plots with minimal disruption to canon.

What Makes This Return Special?

Andrea Hall isn’t just a lookalike. She’s a soap opera legend in her own right. Her past performances, especially as Samantha, were deeply emotional and widely praised. And while Andrea left acting to focus on her career in special education, her 2000 comeback proved she still has the talent and presence to shake up Salem.

She and Deidre even collaborated creatively during the pandemic, working on The Westbrook Collection, a series of watercolor greeting cards, proving their bond and artistic synergy remains strong.

In recent interviews, Deidre Hall has expressed openness to working with Andrea again. She’s described their past experience as “spectacular” and hinted at ideas that would bring their dynamic back to the screen in a fresh, meaningful way.

Fan Buzz and Social Media Frenzy

On fan forums and X (formerly Twitter), chatter about Andrea’s possible return has surged. Comments like “Bring back Andrea Hall for a twin twist!” and “Hattie vs. Marlena in 2025—yes, please!” are lighting up feeds.

Many fans recall the Samantha Evans storyline as one of the most compelling arcs of its time and want to see something similarly iconic to honor the show’s legacy. With milestone episodes like the 15,000th episode in December 2024 and the 60th anniversary just months away, this is the ideal moment for such a tribute.

Potential Roadblocks

Still, there are logistical challenges.

• Andrea retired after her 2001 stint and only returned briefly in 2000. Her willingness to relocate to L.A. again remains uncertain.

• Budget limitations are always a factor in daytime soaps, though Peacock’s streaming model has boosted viewership and possibly resources.

• If Deidre continues actively playing Marlena and Hattie, writers would need to craft a unique narrative to justify Andrea’s return without redundancy.

But Days has always found ways to surprise viewers—just think of Marlena’s possessions, comas, and wild plot twists. If there’s one show that can make the impossible happen, it’s this one.

Final Verdict: Will Andrea Hall Return?

The chances may be slim—but the possibility is tantalizing.

Andrea Hall’s return, even for a short arc, would be a gift to longtime fans and a smart creative move as Days of Our Lives enters its diamond year. Whether reprising Hattie, stepping in as a temporary Marlena, or shocking Salem as an entirely new character, her comeback would be soaked in nostalgia and ripe with fresh storytelling opportunities.

And let’s be honest—seeing the Hall twins light up the screen together again? That’s the kind of daytime magic fans crave.

Your Turn, Salemmites!

What do you think? Would you love to see Andrea Hall return to Days of Our Lives? Should she reprise Hattie, become a new character, or stand in for Marlena?

Drop your thoughts in the comments and keep the speculation going as we countdown to the 60th anniversary of the show that’s defined daytime drama for generations.

And don’t forget—like, subscribe, and stay tuned to TV Days Drama Digest for more updates, spoilers, and love letters to the world of Salem. ⏳🕯️💫